Search
Use code "FR3SH" for free delivery on your first order

Next delivery date: Wednesday, October 6

Change My Zipcode

Change My Zipcode

Please enter your new zipcode below.

Dairy & Eggs

  • Filter
  • bulk
  • Cheese
  • Eggs & Butter
  • Milk & Cream
  • Yogurt
FYF Product Image
$4.75

Eggs, Brown Chicken (1 dz)

Miller Farms
Produced in MO.
+ ADD
This option is currently sold out.
This option is currently unavailable.
This product is currently sold out.
$4.75
Cancel
FYF Product Image
From $1.50

Milk, Whole

Rolling Lawns
Produced in Greenville, IL.
+ ADD
  • Gallon
  • Half-Gallon
  • Quart
  • Single
This option is currently sold out.
This option is currently unavailable.
This product is currently sold out.
$6.50
Cancel
Sold Out
$7.50

Cheese, Fresh Mozzarella (8 oz)

Marcoot Creamery
Produced in Greenville, IL.
FYF Product Image
$5.75

Butter, Salted (8 oz)

Mast Family Creamery
Comes FROZEN. Produced in Salem, MO.
+ ADD
This option is currently sold out.
This option is currently unavailable.
This product is currently sold out.
$5.75
Cancel
FYF Product Image
$5.15

Yogurt, Greek Plain (24 oz)

Windcrest Dairy
Produced in Trenton, IL.
+ ADD
This option is currently sold out.
This option is currently unavailable.
This product is currently sold out.
$5.15
Cancel
FYF Product Image
From $1.50

Milk, Reduced Fat 2%

Rolling Lawns
Produced in Greenville, IL.
+ ADD
  • Gallon
  • Half-Gallon
  • Quart
  • Single
This option is currently sold out.
This option is currently unavailable.
This product is currently sold out.
$6.50
Cancel
FYF Product Image
From $1.90

Milk, Chocolate

Rolling Lawns
Produced in Greenville, IL.
+ ADD
  • Half-Gallon
  • Quart
  • Single
This option is currently sold out.
This option is currently unavailable.
This product is currently sold out.
$5.00
Cancel
$7.50

Cheese, White Cheddar (6 oz)

Marcoot Creamery
Produced in Greenville, IL.
+ ADD
This option is currently sold out.
This option is currently unavailable.
This product is currently sold out.
$7.50
Cancel
FYF Product Image
$5.15

Yogurt, Greek Vanilla (24 oz)

Windcrest Dairy
Produced in Trenton, IL.
+ ADD
This option is currently sold out.
This option is currently unavailable.
This product is currently sold out.
$5.15
Cancel
$5.00

Cheese, Cave Aged Tomme (4 oz)

Marcoot Creamery
Produced in Greenville, IL.
+ ADD
This option is currently sold out.
This option is currently unavailable.
This product is currently sold out.
$5.00
Cancel
$7.50

Cheese, Havarti (6 oz)

Marcoot Creamery
Produced in Greenville, IL.
+ ADD
This option is currently sold out.
This option is currently unavailable.
This product is currently sold out.
$7.50
Cancel
FYF Product Image
From $3.30

Half & Half

Rolling Lawns
Produced in Greenville, IL.
+ ADD
  • Half-Gallon
  • Quart
  • Single
This option is currently sold out.
This option is currently unavailable.
This product is currently sold out.
$9.50
Cancel
FYF Product Image
From $5.25

Cream, Heavy

Rolling Lawns
Produced in Greenville, IL.
+ ADD
  • Half-Gallon
  • Quart
  • Single
This option is currently sold out.
This option is currently unavailable.
This product is currently sold out.
$14.75
Cancel
Sold Out
$5.00

Cheese, Cave Aged Gouda (4 oz)

Marcoot Creamery
Produced in Greenville, IL.
FYF Product Image
From $2.25

Milk, Cappuccino

Rolling Lawns
Produced in Greenville, IL.
+ ADD
  • Quart
  • Single
This option is currently sold out.
This option is currently unavailable.
This product is currently sold out.
$5.00
Cancel
Sold Out
$5.00

Cheese, Cave Aged Heritage (4 oz)

Marcoot Creamery
Produced in Greenville, IL.
FYF Product Image
From $1.50

Milk, Skim

Rolling Lawns
Produced in Greenville, IL.
+ ADD
  • Gallon
  • Half-Gallon
  • Quart
  • Single
This option is currently sold out.
This option is currently unavailable.
This product is currently sold out.
$6.50
Cancel
FYF Product Image
$6.50

Eggs, Duck (1 dz)

Small IL Family Farmer
Produced in IL.
+ ADD
This option is currently sold out.
This option is currently unavailable.
This product is currently sold out.
$6.50
Cancel
FYF Product Image
From $1.90

Milk, Strawberry

Rolling Lawns
Produced in Greenville, IL.
+ ADD
  • Half-Gallon
  • Quart
  • Single
This option is currently sold out.
This option is currently unavailable.
This product is currently sold out.
$5.00
Cancel
Sold Out
$7.50

Cheese, Mauna Loa Cheddar (5 oz)

Marcoot Creamery
Produced in Greenville, IL.
$7.50

Cheese, Smoked Gouda (6 oz)

Marcoot Creamery
Produced in Greenville, IL.
+ ADD
This option is currently sold out.
This option is currently unavailable.
This product is currently sold out.
$7.50
Cancel
FYF Product Image
From $1.90

Milk, Orange Cream

Rolling Lawns
Produced in Greenville, IL.
+ ADD
  • Quart
  • Single
This option is currently sold out.
This option is currently unavailable.
This product is currently sold out.
$3.80
Cancel
Sold Out
$5.00

Cheese, Cave Aged Alpine (4 oz)

Marcoot Creamery
Produced in Greenville, IL.
FYF Product Image
$7.50

Cheese, Kickapoo (5 oz)

Ludwig Farmstead Creamery
Produced in Fithian, IL.
+ ADD
This option is currently sold out.
This option is currently unavailable.
This product is currently sold out.
$7.50
Cancel
FYF Product Image
$5.15

Yogurt, Plain Vanilla (24 oz)

Windcrest Dairy
Produced in Trenton, IL.
+ ADD
This option is currently sold out.
This option is currently unavailable.
This product is currently sold out.
$5.15
Cancel
Sold Out
$7.50

Cheese, Tipsy Cheddar (5 oz)

Marcoot Creamery
Produced in Greenville, IL.
$7.50

Cheese, Hatch Pepper Cheddar (5 oz)

Marcoot Creamery
Small square of cheese. Produced in Greenville, IL.
+ ADD
This option is currently sold out.
This option is currently unavailable.
This product is currently sold out.
$7.50
Cancel
FYF Product Image
$5.15

Yogurt, Plain (24 oz)

Windcrest Dairy
Produced in Trenton, IL.
+ ADD
This option is currently sold out.
This option is currently unavailable.
This product is currently sold out.
$5.15
Cancel
$7.50

Cheese, 5 Alarm Gouda (6 oz)

Marcoot Creamery
Produced in Greenville, IL.
+ ADD
This option is currently sold out.
This option is currently unavailable.
This product is currently sold out.
$7.50
Cancel

Your Cart

Total
$0.00 USD
Shipping & taxes calculated at checkout
Continue Shopping
Your cart is currently empty.
Click here to continue shopping.